Whenever magicians meet, they’re likely to start showing off the latest tricks that they’ve learned—not out of competition, but out of professional camaraderie. It’s that feeling of sharing something intimate between two magicians that Penn & Teller find themselves drawn to, and GeniiOnline got a chance to discuss what it’s like sharing that feeling with a global audience, along with how the duo came up with the judging process for the show.

Be sure to check out our behind-the-scenes with Fool Us winner David Parr, as well as our continuing interview with Penn & Teller.